2020-09-02 - [CNTT - RM Workstream Master] Agenda and Meeting Minutes

2020-09-02 - [CNTT - RM Workstream Master] Agenda and Meeting Minutes

Attendees:

Please add your name in here:

  •  

    • @Walter.kozlowski (Telstra)

    • @Pankaj.Goyal (AT&T)

    • @Per Andersson (Kaloom)

    • @Suresh Krishnan (Deactivated) (Kaloom)

    • @Tom Van Pelt (Deactivated) (GSMA)

    • @Toshi Wakayama (KDDI)

    • @Tomas Fredberg (Ericsson) (Ericsson)

    • @Karine Sevilla (Orange)

    • @Sukhdev Kapur (Juniper)

    • @Ulrich Kleber (Huawei)

    • @Saad Ullah Sheikh

Special Notes:

 

 

  • Weekly RM meetings are intended to

    • Plan RM and Network related work

    • Identify owners for new Issues/PRs

    • Track open Issues/PRs

    • Address technical issues that cannot be resolved online (i.e. resolve stalls)

Agenda:

 

Chapter.Section

Content

Status/Issues

Owner

Comments

Chapter 0

https://github.com/cntt-n/CNTT/tree/master/doc/common

Merged/Closed

 

 

Chapter 1

https://github.com/cntt-n/CNTT/blob/master/doc/ref_model/chapters/chapter01.md

Merged/Closed

 

 

Chapter 2

https://github.com/cntt-n/CNTT/blob/master/doc/ref_model/chapters/chapter02.md

Merged/Closed

 

 

Chapter 3

https://github.com/cntt-n/CNTT/blob/master/doc/ref_model/chapters/chapter03.md

Merged/Closed

 

 

 

Chapter 4.1, 4.2

Address issues

 

Merged/Closed

 

 

 

Chapter 4.3

Network, new content (done)

Merged/Closed

 

 

Chapter 5.1, 5.2 (software)

Address issues

 

Merged/Closed

 

 

 

 

Chapter 5.3, 5.4 (Hardware)

Address issues

 

Merged/Closed

 

 

 

Chapter 6

Address issues

 

Merged/Closed

 

 

Chapter 7

Security

Rewrite, address issue. @Walter.kozlowski review:

  1. Need to add a shared security model in a diagrammatic form? Can be post Baraque if too hard now.

  2. 7.4.1.2 - need to divide into subgroups of related requirements

  3. Need to de-duplicate 7.4.1.2 and  7.4.2, for example introduce a Common requirements group in 7.4.1.2 and refer to it in 7.4.2, and then add specifics for backup-end security

  4. 7.6 (operator's workload responsibility) is different from 7.4.1 (operator's platform responsibility).

  5. 7.9, 7.10, 7.11 need to be reviewed in detail by a security expert; @ZWARICO, AMY can you assist?

GSMA feedback

Issues: 1754, 1755,

 

Karine

@Karine Sevilla  to create a list of sections needed assistance and request help from the group

Clean up issue#1881 CLOSED -> PR #1882 MERGED

But the chapter still needs review and clean up for:

  •  section Root of trust: right place? WK: looks OK to me

  • 7.6 content somehow redundant with 7.4.1 and a lot of details, e.g. on RTM, is it necessary here; WK: see (6) in the left column

  • 7.4.1.2:  list presentation could be enhanced, WK: agreed, see (3,4) in the left column

Walter to contribute to resolve these issues

 

Chapter 8

Conformance, Verification, and Certification

https://github.com/cntt-n/CNTT/blob/master/doc/ref_model/chapters/chapter08.md

Merged/Closed

 

Merged into master

Future updates via separate PRs

Chapter 9

LCM

Address issues

 

GSMA feedback/addressed

 

Contents complete for Baraque.  This topic will need more reviews and updates for the next releases.

 

Chapter 10.3.1

Discovery

New content

Merged/Closed

 

 

Chapter 10.3.2

Load balancing

New content

Merged/Closed

 

 

 

Chapter 10.3.3

Service Function Chain

New content

Merged/Closed

 

 

Chapter 10.3.4

Packet acceleration

New content

Merged/Closed

 

Issue #1861 from @Pankaj.Goyalto be resolved with @Suresh Krishnan (Deactivated)

Chapter 10.3.5

New content

Merged/Closed

 

 

Appendix A

Address issues

 

Merged/Closed

 

 

Overall editing

Address issues

 

GSMA feedback

Issues #1625 (number consistency)

Walter

 

Overall topics for Baraque (per Rabi’s plan)

 

 

 

 

Networking Modelling

Review RM and add/update content

 

Tomas

 

Networking & Storage Characterization

Review RM and add/update content

 

Karine

Petar

Petar updating Chapter 3

Full Containerization support

Review RM and add/update content

 

Walter

 

HW Acceleration support

Review RM and add/update content

 

Ahmed

 

Edge

Review RM and add/update content

 

Ahmed

 

Actions:

 

Minutes: