2020-11-25 - [CNTT - RM Workstream Master] Agenda and Meeting Minutes
Zoom link:
https://zoom.us/j/997256543?pwd=MWptM0F0Y1NpckhFVUgrZnM2TkJ0Zz09
Attendees:
Please add your name in here:
Walter.kozlowski (Telstra)
Pankaj.Goyal (AT&T)
Sukhdev Kapur (Juniper)
Tomas Fredberg (Ericsson) (Ericsson)
Per Andersson (Kaloom)
Suresh Krishnan (Deactivated) (Kaloom)
Petar Torre (Deactivated) (Intel)
Saad Sheikh SID (STC)
Karine Sevilla (Orange)
Tom Van Pelt (Deactivated) (GSMA)
Toshi Wakayama (KDDI)
@Mehmet Toy (Verizon)
Ahmed El Sawaf (stc)
Agenda:
Recording Policies:
Meeting Recording:
Agenda bashing:
Meeting on Hybrid Multi-cloud model and relation to OPG model, after this RM meeting: https://attcorp.webex.com/join/pg683k, CNTT Hybrid Multi-Cloud Architecture - Scenario | Please use CNTT RM PR #2118
Agenda
New time for RM meetings: Wednesdays, 8:00pm UTC, 9:00pm CET, 12:00 pm California, 7:00 am (Thursday) Melbourne
Anuket/Meld: Interim TSC update: Anuket Transition TSC
Next vF2F conference in February 2021: topics are required: Feb vF2F Feb 1-4: 2021 February LFN Developer & Testing Forum
Updates on collaboration and relevant events:
OITF: Reference Model published as an official GSMA document NG.126: https://www.gsma.com/newsroom/wp-content/uploads/NG.126-v1.0.pdf
GSMA OITF/OPG collaboration update (background on OPG: https://www.gsma.com/operatorplatform/)
GSMA Telco Edge Cloud (TEC) white paper: https://infocentre2.gsma.com/gp/pr/FNW/UTEC/Pages/Default.aspx
O-RAN (WG 6) collaboration ver 2 of the design document (Cloud Platform) will be finalised by the end of November (reference conformance for K8s) - Karine will inform the RM team
Akraino proposed collaboration on Edge; RA-1 and RA-2 implementations (RIx) may be of interest fro Akraino; Beth volunteered to participate in one of the meetings (Sukhdev to organise)
Cloud Native Network Functions (CNF) Working Group: https://github.com/cncf/cnf-conformance/pull/450, if you want tp join use this link:
Next release (Elbrus) M3 - 15 January 2021: Update on Elbrus Issues and PRs progress/actions and PRIORITIZATION
MVP: means that we should have an almost ready contents by 20 December 2020
Network/Hardware Management
Hardware Infrastructure Management: function and APIs
Tomas, Walter
High
MVP
Agreed
Issue 2050
Requirements for NBI from HIM: work in progress
Some contents will be available next week
Primary & secondary networking
Tomas, Suresh, Gergely
Medium
MVP
Probably RA-2 topic, discuss with Tom K. Gergely, Georg Kunz, whether RM can help (prob general guidance and requirements)
Issue 2085: work in progress
Some contents will be available next week
Operations
Security (workloads and infrastructure) - alignment with ONAP
Karine, Amy, Pankaj
High
MVP
Agreed
CNCF - Cloud Native Security White Paper - https://github.com/cncf/sig-security/blob/master/security-whitepaper/cloud-native-security-whitepaper.md
More relevant for RA-2, not RM
Life-cycle Management (infrastructure)
Walter, Karine, Pankaj, Per, Uli
Medium
Upgradeability, migration
Action: Issue 2086; identify gaps in Chapter 9 - open fort comments
Chapter 9 contains:
Configuration Management
A bit of Assurance
Few sentences on Capacity Management
Gaps:
Incident Management (Walter)
Problem Management(Walter)
Change Management (including Infrastructure Refresh)(Walter)
Monitoring
Audit
Disaster Recovery
CI/CD (Scott + Pankaj)
Automation (closed loop automation)
Scott, Pankaj, Saad, Tomas, Walter
Medium
Should be in part in LCM (Chapter 9) - identify topics - open for comments; Issue 2087
Action: identify gaps
Infrastructure build automation (Part of RI-1 and RI-2) define process in RM
Tenancy creation automation
Workload onboarding automation
CI/CD Automation (Application Lifecycle automation) (Scott + Pankaj)
Close loop automation
Security automation
Networking
Action: Anyone who wants to pick up any of these topics - please raise your hand
Action: Please send email with your interest to Pankaj pgoyal@att.com, who will organise a call to discuss
Observability/telemetry
Sukhdev, Zlatko, Petar
Medium
MVP
Issue 2052 contains a link to a google document: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1BjRTIPVOs7vqZvvmd65CWX0vJU3YCGcq5McVyyxdXoY/edit?usp=sharing
All: please add comments there
Acceleration
Hardware acceleration abstraction
Petar, Tomas, Per, Walter
High
MVP
Issue 2051; open for comments
Initial text work in progress, plan to share within a week
Compute node acceleration (incl smartNICs, GPU, etc)
TBA
Programmable fabric
TBA
Network acceleration
TBA
Storage
Karine, Petar
Medium
Needed a structure
Further details needed (all classes of storage)
Issue 2056: Need contributors and expertise https://etherpad.opendev.org/p/ecg-vptg-october-2020 it has a link to the June PTG notes
Action: Beth to provide a structure (PTG etherpad can be used)
Special use cases
Load balancing
Per, Sukhdev
Medium
Issue 2095: Per to provide concept description for comments
Mutual discovery (workloads/infrastructure)
Sukhdev, Tomas
Medium
Issue 2088; Sukhdev to add the concept description for comments
Service function chaining
Suresh, Sukhdev
Medium
MVP
Issue 2089; text in Issue
Action: review and comments from the Team
Model for Enterprise Cloud
Walter, Pankaj, Ahmed
Medium
MVP
Issue 2049: Multi/hybrid cloud from Data Centre to Edge; review and update the contents in WiKi:
Action: All to review and add comments:
CNTT Hybrid Multi-Cloud Architecture - Scenario, CNTT Edge Architecture
Alignment with ONAP
Investigate topics other than security
Petar
Low
Petar to present to RM meeting
Alignment with GSMA OPG
Investigate alignment points
Walter
Low
Depends on outcomes of joint OITF and OPG meetings
Alignment with ORAN?
Influence ORAN regarding telco cloud
Tomas raised this question as he participates in WG 6. Karine to find out how we could discuss possible dependences, alignments, cloud principles....
Alignment with ODIM
Martin
Bring to this meeting the actions, comments from previous sessions and vF2F
Granularity of RM profiles
Issue 2068
Action: Walter to invite Tom K to present the view
REview of RM Chapter 2
All
Issues 2067, 2067
Actions: