2020 October Virtual Technical Meetings Daily Summaries

Oct 13, 2020

Track	Key Points	Challenges	Action Items

Track	Key Points	Challenges	Action Items
Cross-Community	Good discussions on how to build a trusting community. Targeted at the CNTT/OPNFV Meld activities, but applies across the LFN and Open Source communities.
ONAP	Session on E2E Network Slicing - Honolulu release Scope and Future Roadmap (Presenters: @LIN MENG, @Swaminathan Seetharaman, @Milind Jalwadi,@Henry Yu) This session covered what functionality has been realized in Guilin, and the proposal for Honolulu and beyond for each of the following tracks of the E2E Network Slicing use case: Enhancements in CSMF and NSMF for E2E Network Slice allocation, standards alignment, operator intervention, etc. RAN, Core and Transport Slicing related aspects, including alignment with O-RAN (RAN) and ETSI ZSM & IETF (Transport) KPI Monitoring, Closed Loop Control & Intelligent Slicing Feedback from the ONAP community was sought on topics such as Network Slicing in roaming scenarios (i.e., true e2e slicing), interaction of slice management & orchestration functions (NxMF) with the Core NFs such as NSSF and NWDAF, collaboration with C&PS project, etc. Presentation Slides are available here.
	ONAP Multi Tenancy - Demo of Guilin work and Roadmap
	ONAP Demo of O-RAN-SC O1 interface simulator configuration via CDS
	ONAP Control Loop in TOSCA PoC and Rel H evolution
	ONAP Orchestration of Free 5G Core CNFs using ONAP4K8s (EMCO)
CNTT/OPNFV	CNTT K8S SURVEY OPNFV TSC Meeting Jerma M2 scheduled for Oct 20 Functional freeze - Readiness Review Document significant accomplishments Release Management Tasks sent to for M2 Goal for Documentation outline in Jerma Release -Agreed Revisions to RELREQ-13 on Storage testing requirements and clarifications - Agreed OPNFV Input to LFN Governing Board meeting on Project's Priority Activities - Agreed Meld Meeting Meld work continues to make great progress. All three workstreams have actions and activities working towards a January 1 transition. Likely that new TSC will be interim to align with the election processes of OPNFV and get the Meld org in sync with rest of LFN
XGVela Project Update & Discussion
EUAG and SDN	EUAG and Software Defined Networking by @Ahmed El Sawaf

Oct 14, 2020

Track	Key Points	Challenges	Action Items

Track	Key Points	Challenges	Action Items
Cross-Community	Multiple engaging discussions on EUAG Exploration of how to expand the scope of EUAG to better address the community needs Telcom operators discussing how to bring a joint operator/vendor perspective.
ONAP	ONAP Requirements Subcommittee - new requirements for Honolulu #1 ONAP ETSI-Alignment (SOL004, SOL005 v3.3.1) #2 E2E Network Slicing use case #3 Smart Operator Intent -based Network & 5G Slicing Support #4 5G OOF SON use case		#2 E2E Network Slicing use case Comment: O-RAN alignment and collaboration seems more pragmatic for the upcoming releases, than the other topics such as slicing in roaming scenarios, etc. Comment: Clarify what exactly is meant by O-RAN alignment to avoid misinterpretation.
ONAP	ONAP Impact of the current ONAP release- and branching strategy on documentation Discussed the possible solutions for branching documentation and project / Cross release issues.	Several projects have deprecated repos Documentation update tracking should be part of release process should documentation be in a single repo ?
ONAP	ONAP Security Subcommittee Kanban Review Helm, OS, Python/java updates Update Vulnerable direct depencies (tracking through wiki) M1 (TBD) commit resources M4 (TBD) complete upgrades Guilin seccom retrospective : lots of improvements in this release Reviewed H release priorities
	ONAP Architecture Subcommittee update: Guilin Reviews perspectives and what's new for Honolulu
ONAP	ONAP TCC Network Management ETSI ETSI NFV update – Thinh Nguyenphu ONAP Conformance to ETSI – Byung-Woo Jun 3GPP RAN Slicing: 5G NR Resource Configuration Management – Kamel Idir TM Forum Digital Transformation World – Magnus Buhrgard Catalysts, rapid-fire proof-of-concept projects – Magnus Buhrgard
ONAP	ONAP Honolulu - CNF Task Force Requirements Presentation of REQ-334 (ETSI Alignment-CNF Support) - SOL004, SOL005 v3.3.1 REQ-341 (CNF Orchestrator)		Call for Developers for the Honolulu Release If any interest then please contact REQ-334: @Fernando Oliveira , @Byung-Woo Jun REQ-341: @Lukasz Rajewski , @Seshu Kumar Mudiganti Consider portability between ETSI & ONAP for CNF
ONAP	ONAP: Hands-on session on ONAP Optimization Framework (OOF) This session provided an overview of OOF, its modular architecture, capabilities and ease of reuse w.r.to onboarding a new use case or requirement that needs some sort of optimization functionality. It also described the typical realization steps to follow for any use case or requirement needing optimization (provided by OOF). It was followed by a guided walk-through with an example of how the E2E Network Slicing use case realized the optimization needs easily through a lot of reuse of existing functionality with some enhancements. Comment: Policy team highly appreciated the work done by OOF team for effective usage of the new Policy framework. Query: A query on how subnet instance's resource occupancy levels and capability of an existing instance to cater to a new request are considered by OOF. Response: This isn't yet considered by OOF, however, it is proposed to be realized in Honolulu release, with OOF getting the required info on available resources and capacity through an "inventory provider" which for example could be AAI or DCAE, which leverages existing OOF capabilities to a large extent. Presentation slides are available here.
CNTT/OPNFV	Field trial by Orange reviewed Next OVP revision documentation update planning Very engaged conversation on Telemetry and Observability HA requirements got into the obligation of defining the test approach vs. implementation. ODIM Project gave an overview of the project, with the CNTT RM team describing how the Hardware Interface Manager (HIM) concept can be addressed by ODIM. Several key areas were identified for collaboration. The ODIM team will continue the dialog in RM meetings and RA meetings afterwards, at the appropriate time.
CNTT	CNTT - Telemetry/Observability architecture - a path to full automation this session presented an architecture for the Telemetry/Observability of VNFs and Cloud Infrastructure (NFVI) to achieve full automation leading to zero touch operation. This architecture is based on a central telemetry data BUS on which are connected Providers Consumers and Subscribers of telemetry data.		2020-10-14 - CNTT - Telemetry/Observability architecture - a path to full automation
xGVela
Tungsten Fabric	Unified Life Cycle Management using TF Operator - integration with Airship Discussed approach on unification of life cycle management of Tungsten Fabric using Tungsten Fabric operator and provided reference implementation of an integration with Airship
Tungsten Fabric	Transparency of TF Community Shared details around documentation, governance, release management and related topics, community has made significant progess in recent days. looking forward to take it further as a collaborative effort. Callout for new contributors and participants for Tungsten Fabric community		@Sukhdev Kapur identified some of the documentation that needs to be migrated from opencontrail google drive to wiki.tungsten.io
Tungsten Fabric	TF Feature Development Roadmap Discussed details on the 2020/2021 roadmap items with focus around cloud-native, dpdk, datapath and some other areas		@Prabhjot Singh Sethi we can consider looking forward to phase out kernel module vrouter, will carry further discussions around this in community @Prabhjot Singh Sethi @Nick Davey to work out possiblity of setting up a collaboration as a sub group for cloud native effort
Tungsten Fabric	TF vRouter - New debug and troubleshooting tools Presented a session on new debug and troubleshooting tools inducted for datapath		consider further sessions and discussion around debuggability in community calls @Kiran KN needs to migrate documentation to wiki.tungsten.io
Tungsten Fabric	TF Cloud Native Discussion Discussion around cloud native work happening in tungsten fabric. Also presented a demo on Tungsten Fabric integration with envoy proxy

Oct 15, 2020

Track	Key Points	Challenges	Action Items

Track	Key Points	Action Items
Cross-Community	PLEASE FILL OUT THE EVENT SURVEY: https://www.surveymonkey.com/r/LFNTech PLEASE REGISTER IF YOU HAVE NOT: https://www.cvent.com/d/k7q1mh/4W?ct=50221cf5-5496-4c34-9ec0-3b52b1bf1204&_ga=2.21073848.2005020082.1597615801-222812119.1571605958&_gac=1.250209970.1597348253.EAIaIQobChMIuJ2l9vmY6wIVEh-tBh3_KApSEAAYASAAEgLU1fD_BwE
ONAP	Policy Framework Guilin key updates. Detailed working session & demo of Xacml-PDP engine. Detailed working session & demo of Apex-PDP. Detailed working session & demo of Drools-PDP engine. Plans for Honolulu release All the details (slides, postman collection etc) are available here - https://wiki.onap.org/display/DW/2020-10-15+October+LFN+Virtual+Technical+Meetings
ONAP	ETSI ZSM - ONAP architecture collaboration	External interface of TSC (NBI) still need to be implemented Otherwise the TN NSSMF is part of the Guilin Release Call for Developers to implement Closed-Loop Automation as part of Honolulu and upcoming releases
ONAP	ONAP: O-RAN ↔ ONAP Collaboration and Alignment Presentation slides are available here. ONAP 5G & PNF use cases aligned with O-RAN & 3GPP	Provide a monthly update to the ONAP TSC O-RAN members will join @Benjamin Cheung ONAP's weekly session Feel free to contact our O-RAN Liaison from the ONAP Community: @Swaminathan Seetharaman @Tracy Van Brakle will share the next O-RAN/ONAP Plugfest Joint Sessions Link to ONAP Liaisons and Technical Community Coordinators https://wiki.onap.org/display/DW/Technical+Community+Coordinators+and+ONAP+Liaisons Rittwik Jana is the O-RAN SC TSC representative for the O-RAN Requirements Document the details of alignment & collaboration on ONAP wiki. Continue the alignment discussions with O-RAN-SC on the weekly ONAP/O-RAN-SC/SMO meeting on Wed.
ONAP	ONAP: A1 Policy enforcement with Non-RT RIC
ONAP	ONAP Honolulu - What Should We Improve?
ONAP	ONAP: Guilin CNF improvements overview	Support for container repository in the proposed approach - integration with ETSI path Long direction - service orchestration with TOSCA based composition where helm package can be replaced by TOSCA definition?
ONAP	CONFIGURATION PERSISTENCE SERVICE
ONAP	ONAP: 5G OOF SON use case - Honolulu release requirements, dependencies and roadmap Presentation slides are available here.
ONAP	What's New in ONAP Frankfurt
CNTT/OPNFV	Edge Workstream Review of Edge Workstreams work on what profiles need to be addressed in the reference architectures and model. 2020-10-15 - CNTT Edge Work stream Working Session CNTT Edge - RA01 ( OpenStack ) Architecture - Scenario OVP 2.0 Input on CNF Workload requirements - Requirements for the Infrastructure make sense and there should be a test on the infrastructure to ensure that the workload requirements are met. Requirements drive the tests that are developed. --- having Workload requirements BEYOND the above is thought to be out of scope for CNTT & OPNFV. Several people agreed or seemed to agree on this. OPNFV Investigates CNTT Telemetry Req. with AIRSHIP and Barometer Projects Study of current coverage with Prometheus and need for collectd support: CNTT provides the Use Case for OpenStack dev that was missing before. Reviewed status of collectd and Prometheus capabilities studies (RELREQ-18) Discussed possibility of reviving collectd effort in OS Helm that was abandoned about 3 years ago for lack of a compelling use case Emma / James to review code and scope the effort to get it running Al to request item on CNTT TSC agenda for next week to approach OS Helm about enabling collectd OPNFV Kuberef project review - Relies on BMRA (new) installer for now, others welcome. Testing the new Gitlab CI/CD environment from a green-field point of view (new project).
xGVela
OpenDaylight	ODL-Micro Aluminium updates Meeting Notes ODl-Micro VDF Slides