EUAG 2020-07-28 Meeting notes

EUAG 2020-07-28 Meeting notes

Date

Jul 28, 2020

Attendees

LF Staff: Jim Baker  Kenny Paul (Deactivated) Brandon Wick
Committee Members: Atul Purohit (Nokia) Lei Huang  Ahmed El Sawaf  Javier Ger Ken KANISHIMA Yoshihiro Nakajima Ryan Hallahan Fernando Oliveira Marc-Alexandre Choquette FREEMAN, BRIAN D
Guests: Scott Blandford
Proxies:

Agenda

  • Start the Recording

  • Antitrust Policy

  • Agenda Bashing (Roll Call, Action Items (5 minutes)

  • General Topics

    • 5G adoption white paper proposal Atul Purohit (Nokia)

    • ONAP requirements process Lei Huang

    • Expand beyond ONAP focus Jim Baker

    • Any other announcements

Minutes

5G adoption white paper proposal - Atul Purohit (Nokia)

  • LFN Governing Board (GB) asked about gaining insight into 5G from the membership.

  • Atul Purohit (Nokia) shared a proposal for producing a 5G whitepaper.

  • A request from Arpit Joshipura for EUAG to work with LFN Marketing &  James Crawshaw to discuss 5G 

  • 3 key focus areas for introductory guides from LFN coming from the MAC

  • a detailed EUAG white paper on 5G should be complementary to the intro guides

  • Feedback on proposal

    • Ahmed El Sawaf Not covering relationship with TIP and Open Core? 

    • Should bring a solid usecase into our white paper bringing in the opensource mindset

    • Lei Huang A survey could be basis for challenges and use cases - Volunteering to produce survey

    • Scott Blandford 5G covers a lot of area - is there a specific focal point or ways to limit the scope?

      • While LFN addresses a limited amount of 5G features, the white paper is not constrained to just LFN pieces

      • Proposals: Operation deployment perspective, Operator view of 5G

    •  Ryan Hallahan What is the objective? Lead LFN projects? Direct new project focus? What is the desired outcome?@jav

      • Plenty of open ended 5G challenges white papers/blogs out there, so little value in that.

    • Javier Ger should take entire ecosystem into account - perhaps not a specific company name - but cover relationships

      •  Similar to a request from Heather Kirksey (Deactivated) some time ago that covers how LFN touches the different aspects of the carrier space

      • Possible an edge use case may be appropriate

      • Possibly a set of white papers - a very broad 5G, then a followup based upon detailed survey data

EUAG requirements process from experience with ONAP - Javier Ger and Lei Huang

  • ONAP Requirements Subcommittee has asked for some template work to align input

  • Gap in the process exists

  • Atul Purohit (Nokia) reminds folks that not all members of the EUAG are participants or even members of LFN not everyone sees what is going on behind the scenes.

  • for ONAP the Requirements Subc will be presenting the input to the ONAP TSC - potential exists for this model to be propagated to other LFN Projects

  • Javier Ger the level of requirements detail from the EUAG is much higher level than the details needed in Jira ticket

    • We can compare our input for the Guilin release to compare to what format the ONAP Requirements Subc would like to see 

Expand beyond ONAP focus

  • Discussions with Arpit Joshipura on how to grow EUAG participation in other LFN Projects and gain participation of additional carriers.

  • Ahmed El Sawaf Recruit operators that are in CNTT but not in EUAG

EUAG Chair election

  • Atul Purohit (Nokia) moving on from Vodafone.

  • Election for a new Chair ends on the Jul 30, 2020  Ballots previously distributed.

Action items

Atul Purohit (Nokia) upload the white paper proposal to these minutes Jul 28, 2020
Jim Baker Create a survey for determining the 5G white paper topic with results by Aug 11, 2020 
Lei Huang upload the requirements process slides to these minutes Jul 28, 2020 
Jim Baker  Will communicate the outreach activities to the EUAG before Aug 11, 2020